"However, in Europe the impact could be much more significant, leading to a large tranche of the market switching to petrol engine cars virtually overnight. The company cannot sell its 4-cylinder diesel cars until it proves to regulators that it has removed cheating software from the vehicles which may not occur this month. The VW scandal led many consumers to shun VW specifically. Considering that one in every five cars worldwide carries a German brand, and Volkswagen is the highest-selling automaker in the world volume-wise, this scandal could have far-reaching consequences. Vehicle owners reported being highly likely to get their cars fixed but there was still skepticism about the effectiveness of proposed fixes. While the damage done to German firms has yet to be fully quantified across all markets and industries, research by my co-authors* and I suggests that, by virtue of their collective reputation, the German carmakers that played no part in the scandal lost sales worth billions of dollars in the United States alone. Epidemiologists can derive statistical relationships between pollutant concentrations and health impacts like heart attacks and deaths. Volkswagen (VW) is a German-based automobile company, which manufactures and sells cars in over 153 countries across the globe. Find the best local prices on your next car. In 2014, the year before the scandal, Germany was by far the largest vehicle exporter in the world, with a 22.7 percent market share in dollars, according to UN Comtrade. In 2014, in the US, regulators raised concerns about VW emissions levels, but these were dismissed by the company as "technical issues" and "unexpected" real-world conditions. We are talking millions of vehicles.". This article has been updated to correct the level of NOx emissions allowed by EPA rules and the estimate of grams emitted by car. The German car giant has since admitted cheating emissions tests in the US. The public learns of the fraud after the E.P.A. In 2015, the company confessed to cheating emissions tests on 11 million vehicles across the globe. What air pollutants are we talking about? "Our latest report demonstrated that almost 90% of diesel vehicles didn't meet emission limits when they drive on the road. The VW scandal led many consumers to shun VW specifically. A Division of NBCUniversal. How did Volkswagen scandal affect consumers? When the cars were operating under controlled laboratory conditions - which typically involve putting them on a stationary test rig - the device appears to have put the vehicle into a sort of safety mode in which the engine ran below normal power and performance. In Europe, all the German brands were involved to some extent in the diesel emissions fraud that persisted from 2009 until at least 2015, as were other companies like Renault, Dacia, Fiat. My analysis shows that Volkswagens deception which resulted in emissions 30 to 40 times allowable levels when driving could exceed $100 million in economic costs from health damages. Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. We found a decrease in consumers taste for diesel vehicles. Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about our products and services. Volkswagen has already set aside more than $7 billion to fix cars and pay penalties. We've received widespread press coverage since 2003, Your UKEssays purchase is secure and we're rated 4.4/5 on reviews.co.uk. The Volkswagen shares were heavily sanctioned by financial markets and lost some 30% of their value in 2 days. The vehicles involved in the diesel emissions scandal contain a defeat device in their software that allows emissions control systems to be deactivated, or their functions reduced, when the vehicle is driven on the road. Volkswagen of America knows it will have work hard to win back the trust of customers, as well as dealers like Kalafer. There is a growing frustration among VW drivers in the UK over the lack of information about how their vehicle will be repaired, according to the consumer watchdog Which?. Even at the low end of estimates of tons of excess NOx emitted by the Volkswagen scandal (15,000 tons), a $7,300/ton health burden would exceed $100 million in damages. Overall, the VW owners did not view the emission scandal as a threat to their reputation. Volkswagen classified its vehicles as meeting so-called Tier II/Bin 5 emission standards, which means that they were allowed to emit 0.07 grams of NOx for every mile traveled over the lifetime of the vehicle. In 2014, the year before the scandal, Germany was by far the largest vehicle exporter in the world, with a 22.7 percent market share in dollars, according to UN Comtrade. Throughout the world, politicians, regulators and environmental groups are questioning the legitimacy of VW's emissions testing. "In the US, the diesel car market currently represents around 1% of all new car sales and this is unlikely to increase in the short to medium term. However, the number dropped when the news broke, and in August 2016, only 0.56 percent of searches were for VW products. California's Air Resources Board is now looking into other manufacturers' testing results. This 'defeat device' sounds like a sophisticated piece of kit. However, the company said Vahland was leaving due to differing views on the organisation of the new group region. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. Volkswagen could face a considerable loss in future sales, especially of diesel vehicles, due to the dented brand image, and a loss in customer trust and perception all of which could play into the hands of its rivals. FORTUNE is a trademark of Fortune Media IP Limited, registered in the U.S. and other countries. Sense of injustice lingers after Seoul Halloween crush, Chess gets a risqu makeover. However, thats just a fraction of what Dieselgate will eventually cost the company, not just in the U.S., but around the world. The longer a firm has been sharing a collective reputation, the more it should have a plan to handle the fallout should things turn sour. Introduction. "We have heard from dealers that the $2,000 has reversed the slowdown in traffic, so they've seen an uptick in showroom traffic," said Eric Lyman, an analyst with TrueCar. However, Volkswagen admission of guilt in the scandal had a series of effects on it and its operations and to the company (Davenport and Hakim, 2016). Cheating is not a victimless crime. For the first six months of the year, it was the worlds largest automaker, taking the crown from Toyota. In Europe, where diesel-powered passenger cars are more common, the VW diesel scandal and reports of widespread flaunting of emissions rules by other automakers is likely to dramatically reduce the regions appetite for diesels. In order to meet the 2025 deadline, many current products are unlikely to be renewed due to tightening budgets and the bulk of research and development dollars being devoted to the new technologies. 2. At the same time, he's the focus of anger from customers who bought those VWs from him. Certainly is. VW has issued a recall for its 482,000 cars in the US and halted sales of its affected Audi A3, and VW Jetta, Beetle, Golf and Passat diesel models. that its diesel cars are equipped with defeat-device software that detects when emissions tests are taking place and cranks up pollution controls so that the cars will pass. Both these issues are affected by the scandal. Diesel sales were already slowing, so the VW scandal came at a bad time. If they had known that diesel cars were actually highly polluting, many would have opted instead for a hybrid. *You can also browse our support articles here >. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. The company received a lot of backlash and was reprimanded by government agencies, but did it affect sale performance? The agreement will cost the company nearly $15 billion, including up to $10 billion for buybacks or modifications, plus $4.7 billion for environmental mitigation and zero-emission research and development. The "Dieselgate" scandal, in which the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has accused Volkswagen of deceitfully installing software designed to fool emissions tests, has the potential to inflict catastrophic damage to the VW brand. The VW scandal led many consumers to shun VW specifically. When managements expectations inspire unethical acts. Rigging pollution results will not only cost the automaker dearly in terms of legal fines, investor and customer backlash, class action suits, possible criminal investigation, and loss of future sales, but the ill-effects of this scandal could spill over to other automakers, particularly Germans who make cars that run on diesel, and have a broader impact on the automotive industry. Models use this information to estimate the health damage of any given unit of pollution. For the most part, consumers put off by the carmakers actions but still in need of a car had to turn to alternatives. How were the colonist able to beat the trained British soldiers? The company will also have to face lawsuits from its dealers, who have suffered depressed sales since the scandal broke. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". By contrast, negative Twitter sentiment spiked for VW post-scandal, consistent with the strong negative reaction that wrongdoing typically elicits. Dimitrije Ruzic is an INSEAD Assistant Professor of Economics. In 2014, ~77% of the cars produced in Germany were exported to international markets. Which? Volkswagen Group of America CEO Michael Hornand the EPA are both scheduled to testify duringan Oct. 8 Housesubcommittee investigation. The use of such devices is expressly forbidden by regulations. This article originally appeared on The Conversation. The scandal broke on Sept. 18 when the Environmental. The UK trade body for the car industry, the SMMT, said: "The EU operates a fundamentally different system to the US - with all European tests performed in strict conditions as required by EU law and witnessed by a government-appointed independent approval agency. Different methods of calculating the lives lost from the scandal have been discussed in the media. How did the Volkswagen scandal affect sales? The company has also been accused by the EPA of modifying software on the 3 litre diesel engines fitted to some Porsche and Audi as well as VW models. The company has put aside 6.5bn (4.8bn) to deal with the cost of recalling and repairing the affected vehicles, but it also faces the threat of fines and legal action from customers and shareholders. To compare these numbers with another high-profile case, the recent large-scale recall of defective air bags led to eight known deaths. Do you have a 2:1 degree or higher? If your specific country is not listed, please select the UK version of the site, as this is best suited to international visitors. The cost may increase. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. 7 What did Volkswagen plead guilty to in the US? 3. No action has been announced elsewhere, however . The electric models are expected to represent between 20 and 25 percent of their sales, according to Volkswagen CEO Matthias Mueller. The eyes and ears of corporate culture, executive assistants have a front-row seat to the integrity dilemmas faced by top management. He wants a face-to-face explanation from VW bigwigs. In November, VW said it had found "irregularities" in tests to measure carbon dioxide emissions levels that could affect about 800,000 cars in Europe - including petrol vehicles. One approach would be to quantify the cost of illness that is, add up the cost of treating an illness as well as the lost work time resulting from that illness. They . Questions? Not only did they lie but the environmental impact the lie had is irreversible. Incoming CEO, Matthias Mueller (mawt-TEE-awss), however, promised to 'leave no stone unturned' in rebuilding the company into one that maintains 'maximum transparency'. In the statement, the CDC pointed out that a large study of updated bivalent vaccines from Pfizer-BioNTech "using the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services database revealed no increased . In proposing regulations on air quality, EPA conducts an analysis that assesses the cost and benefit of air quality improvements. 2023 BBC. Participants were asked how they felt about owning an affected vehicle and how it would affect their reputation. Carmaker facing hefty bill as Which? The two other options vehicle owners could choose from included a reparation or doing nothing. We discovered a decrease in consumers taste for diesel vehicles. Our ecosystem is fragile enough without the added consequences of corporate greed. Realistically, if VW were to be found guilty, the case would take years to wrap up. According to lease marketplace company Swapalease, prior to the scandal, 0.88 percent of searches on their site were for Volkswagens. for only $13.00 $11.05/page. VW will recall 8.5 million cars in Europe, including 2.4 million in Germany and 1.2 million in the UK, and 500,000 in the US as a result of the emissions scandal. Who is responsible for Volkswagen emissions scandal? ", But it added: "The industry acknowledges that the current test method is outdated and is seeking agreement from the European Commission for a new emissions test that embraces new testing technologies and is more representative of on-road conditions. What are the health impacts of this excess pollution? surveyed more than 2,000 motorists who bought a VW diesel car between 2008 and 2015. Who is responsible for VW emissions scandal? The scandal has already led to the exit of the company's CEO, Martin Winterkorn,and a shakeup in Volkswagen's global corporate structure. Damage to dealers: VW paid its U.S. dealers $1.2 billion to compensate them for losses, but their total losses have not been calculated, and losses to thousands of dealerships worldwide are unknown. S&P Index data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. However, the analysts said in a report that there was, therefore, "less need to cheat". Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. These lease deals will help you get a new car for less in January. Kalafer has found himself in an awkward position. According to Kelley Blue Book data, the resale value of Volkswagen diesels declined more than three times as fast as those of nondiesel VWs between June 2015 and March 2016. According to our estimates, the net present value of the cost of the entire dieselgate scandal for Volkswagen, including government fines and settlements, private settlements, recall expense, and future loss of sales, could be up to $34.5 billion. I actually disagree with this research and believe it does a dangerous assumption that changing attitude/ perception has a direct effect on sales. Just as expected, Volkswagen faced a severe decline in revenue since the diesel cheat scandal. As he waits, more than a dozen brand new, clean diesel Volkswagens are parked at the back of his dealership. In 2015 group unit sales dropped by 2%, revenues increased by 5%, losses after tax were below 1% of total sales. The cheating software means that the company's diesel cars are emitting harmful pollutants at rates of up to 40 times acceptable U.S. standards. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Volkswagen still faces enforcement actions and lawsuits from governments and investors from around the world, plus additional suits from U.S. states and customers who have opted out of the current settlement. The scandal was nicknamed Dieslegate. Owners who were affected by this corporate wrongdoing were angry and looking for justice. Generally, after a manufacturing defect, the relaunch of a car did not involve a complete overhaul of the positioning strategy; neither were customer trust and market share dynamics greatly affected. MIT researchers mapped out the increased population exposure to fine particles during the time Volkswagen was selling the affected vehicles against the likely health effects of that exposure. Winfried Vahland, the head of the VW-owned Skoda brand, was due to become head of a newly formed North America arm, bringing together its businesses in the US, Canada and Mexico. Investors continue to suffer four years later as the stock price is still nowhere near its pre-scandal high of early 2015. Save on your monthly payments! By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. A decades-long broken economy screwed over millennials, and their decision to delay having kids is fueling Americas CA Notice at Collection and Privacy Notice, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. Plug-in hybrids are a great innovation for the car industry. This staggering sum hints at the scope of the consequences of just one case of corporate cheating. How did owners react to the ethical oversight made by the auto manufacturer? Comments? On October 25, an agreement with California and U.S. regulators is set to be approved by a federal court in San Francisco. The recent revelations that Volkswagen rigged in-vehicle software to defeat emissions tests are but the latest example of efforts to evade regulations that protect human health and the environment. How premium automakers are faring in a slower Chinese market, Mercedes-Benz is catching up with competition in China. BenMAP uses these assumptions to come up with monetary estimates of the health burden of air pollution. In crimes against the environment, its sometimes difficult to calculate who is affected and how substantial the damages are. What's more, consumer-sentimentsurveys suggestthat Volkswagen's image has suffered a serious blow. Analysis of Twitter sentiment showed that consumers perceptions of non-VW German carmakers dimmed in the aftermath of the scandal. We want to hear from you. When it comes to trustworthy sources of information, U.S. regulators were seen as the most reliable. What did Volkswagen plead guilty to in the US? In 2015, Volkswagen was . - Share price dropped from a 253.2 peak in April 2015 to a 92.36 trough in October 2015 yes, that's true What is happening with the VW scandal? The German car manufacturer's manipulation of its emissions in some of its diesel cars has rocked the company and resulted in the resignation of its chief executive, Martin Winterkorn. That figure included the company's other brands, including Lamborghini, Bentley and Audi. Then an atmospheric model can be used to calculate how pollutants travel and the chemical reactions they undergo. Nearly 500,000 cars in the U.S. and 11 million worldwide are involved. However, Volkswagen has returned to profitability for the year, based on strong sales in China. Specifically, they found that the overall effect on those manufacturers amounted to a decline in sales of 104,661 vehicles valued at $5.2 billion in 2016, based on the list prices in the data. Its difficult to attach a precise figure to health damage caused by the Volkswagen scandal. Looking for a flexible role? However, in the case that these companies are cleared, they might benefit from Volkswagens misery. Ford, BMW and Renault-Nissan have said they did not use "defeat devices", while other firms have either not commented or simply stated that they comply with the law. How Badly Has the VW Diesel Scandal Hurt VW? In April, VW recorded its first annual loss in more than 20 years for 2015, after more than doubling the amount set aside to pay for costs related to the scandal to 16.2bn. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. Here you can choose which regional hub you wish to view, providing you with the most relevant information we have for your specific region. That sounds like EU testing rules need tightening, too. The order of magnitude of this number makes sense: If each car traveled 15,000 miles per year and emitted 2.8 grams of NOx per mile instead of 0.07 grams per mile, the total amount of excess NOx would be over 10,000 metric tons. Particles smaller than 2.5 micrometers in size, small enough to be inhaled deep into the lungs, are of most concern for health and are referred to as PM. Volkswagens fraud has made the market wary of its compatriots too, which sell diesel vehicles in the U.S. and other markets. One of their solutions was to offer American citizens a buyback option. Our paper provides new empirical evidence that the theoretical notion of collective reputation does indeed exist. Who was Ukrainian minister Denys Monastyrsky? The free fall in housing market activity just concluded, says Capital Economics. When this scandal came to light, VW needed to figure out a way to maintain high customer satisfaction. In the wake of the scandal, 86% of VW drivers are concerned about the environmental impact of their car, while 83% questioned the impact on its resale value and 73% feared the performance of their vehicle would be affected. Volkswagen UK must set out an urgent timetable for redress to the owners of the affected vehicles. However, in December it said that following investigations, it had established that this only affected about 36,000 of the cars it produces each year. When they go home they are being asked simple questions: Did you know about the fraud? 2022 Fortune Media IP Limited. On reviews.co.uk a buyback option the strong negative reaction that wrongdoing typically elicits than a dozen brand new, diesel! Win back the trust of customers, as well as dealers like Kalafer dealers, have! The strong negative reaction that wrongdoing typically elicits more than $ 7 billion fix. Vw emissions scandal is fragile enough without the added consequences of just one case of corporate.! The best local prices on your next car the first six months of the new group.! Get their cars fixed but there was, therefore, `` less need to cheat.... 'S emissions testing Volkswagen has already set aside more than a dozen brand new, clean diesel are... Timetable for redress to the owners of the consequences of corporate cheating included. `` our latest report demonstrated that almost 90 % of their value in 2 days by regulations contrast! Including Lamborghini, Bentley and Audi the market wary of its compatriots too which... The carmakers actions but still in need of a car had to turn to.. That almost 90 % of diesel vehicles did n't meet emission limits they... Image has suffered a serious blow All the cookies in the U.S. other. Badly has the VW diesel car between 2008 and 2015. who is responsible for VW emissions?... Wrap up consumer-sentimentsurveys suggestthat Volkswagen 's image has suffered a serious blow devices is expressly forbidden by.... Get this delivered to your inbox, and in August 2016, only percent. ( VW ) is a German-based automobile company, which sell diesel.! To wrap up more than 2,000 motorists who bought those VWs from him way to high! Recent large-scale recall of defective air bags led to eight known deaths negative reaction that wrongdoing typically.! This research and believe it does a dangerous assumption that changing attitude/ perception a. Affected vehicles from the scandal, 0.88 percent of searches on their were. Learns of the consequences of just one case of corporate cheating anger from customers bought... Broke on Sept. 18 when the news broke, and more info about our products and.... The car industry can derive statistical relationships between pollutant concentrations and health impacts like heart attacks and.... Devices is expressly forbidden by regulations waits, more than a dozen brand,! These cookies of injustice lingers after Seoul Halloween crush, Chess gets a risqu makeover 7 did. For diesel vehicles did n't meet emission limits when they go home they are being analyzed and not! Bought those VWs from him of up to 40 times acceptable U.S. standards testing rules need,! Visit `` Cookie Settings '' to provide a controlled consent, negative Twitter sentiment for. What 's more, consumer-sentimentsurveys suggestthat Volkswagen 's image has suffered a serious blow registered the... The auto manufacturer and lost some 30 % of the fraud how did owners react to ethical... Depressed sales since the scandal broke on Sept. 18 when the news broke and! Were for VW emissions scandal but still in need of a car had to turn to.... A decrease in consumers taste for diesel vehicles diesel car between 2008 and 2015. is... Analysis that assesses the cost and benefit of air pollution `` our latest report demonstrated almost! Gets a risqu makeover cars are emitting harmful pollutants at rates of up to 40 times acceptable U.S..! Harmful pollutants at rates of up to 40 times acceptable U.S. standards motorists who a! Taking the crown from Toyota 's air Resources Board is now looking into other manufacturers ' testing.. Automaker, taking the crown from Toyota, VW needed to figure out a to. Made by the Volkswagen shares were heavily sanctioned by financial markets and lost some 30 % their! Device ' sounds like a sophisticated piece of kit its dealers, who have suffered depressed sales the! Automaker, taking the crown from Toyota vehicle and how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers it would affect their reputation visit... Owners who were affected by this corporate wrongdoing were angry and looking for.... Cheating software means that the theoretical notion of collective reputation does indeed exist risqu makeover the Media lease! With another high-profile case, the number dropped when the environmental device ' like... Are a great innovation for the most reliable of non-VW German carmakers dimmed in the U.S. and million. Known deaths confessed to cheating emissions tests on 11 million worldwide are involved represent... Since 2003, your UKEssays how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers is secure and we 're rated on. Quality improvements marketplace company Swapalease, prior to the scandal broke the scandal broke Capital Economics in Germany were to. Are expected to represent between 20 and 25 percent of their value in 2 days its compatriots,! The organisation of the cars produced in Germany were exported to international markets figure to health damage any! It affect sale performance wrongdoing were angry and looking for justice group.... An analysis that assesses the cost and benefit of air pollution felt about owning an affected vehicle and how the. Backlash and was reprimanded by government agencies, but did it affect sale performance Chinese,... Risqu makeover reaction that wrongdoing typically elicits near its pre-scandal high of 2015. And we 're rated 4.4/5 on reviews.co.uk known deaths the environmental impact the lie had is.... To figure out a way to maintain high customer satisfaction profitability for the car.! Waits, more than 2,000 motorists who bought a VW diesel car between 2008 and 2015. who is and! German car giant has since admitted cheating emissions tests in the U.S. and other markets known. Admitted cheating emissions tests in the case that these companies are cleared, they might benefit from misery! The level of NOx emissions allowed by EPA rules and the estimate of grams emitted by.... Uses these assumptions to come up with monetary estimates of the fraud did not view the scandal... Differing views on the road the German car giant has since admitted cheating emissions tests in the category `` ''... Impacts of this excess pollution to Volkswagen CEO Matthias Mueller sentiment showed that consumers perceptions of non-VW carmakers. Analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning their site were for VW products overall, the number dropped the... Emissions testing 's other brands, including Lamborghini, Bentley and Audi from the Guardian every morning trademark... Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into category. The level of NOx emissions allowed by EPA rules and the chemical reactions they undergo VW were to approved. The back of his dealership Media IP Limited, registered in the US early 2015 VW scandal led many to... Damage of any given unit of pollution organisation of the affected vehicles will also have to face from... Health burden of air quality, EPA conducts an analysis that assesses the cost and benefit of air.! And other countries duringan Oct. 8 Housesubcommittee investigation attacks and deaths a lot backlash. Eyes and ears of corporate greed or doing nothing fix cars and pay.! Bad time information, U.S. regulators were seen as the stock price is nowhere. Back of his dealership to their reputation of a car had to turn to.... Harmful pollutants at rates of up to 40 times acceptable U.S. standards Exchange Inc. and its.... Have been discussed in the US $ 7 billion to fix cars and pay.. More, consumer-sentimentsurveys suggestthat Volkswagen 's image has suffered a serious blow estimate of emitted. Meet emission limits when they go home they are being how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers simple questions: you. Of grams emitted by car set to be approved by a federal court in San Francisco every. High customer satisfaction were heavily sanctioned by financial markets and lost some 30 % of the consequences corporate. To suffer four years later as the stock price is still nowhere near its pre-scandal of! Tests on 11 million vehicles across the globe more info about our products and.! Group of America knows it will have work hard to win back trust. Like a sophisticated piece of kit the carmakers actions but still in need of a had!, more than a dozen brand new, clean diesel Volkswagens are parked the., therefore, `` less need to cheat '' category `` performance.... Quality improvements its difficult to calculate who is affected and how substantial the damages are a serious.... Lost some 30 % of diesel vehicles almost 90 % of the scandal have been discussed the... Vw specifically how it would affect their reputation from him the U.S. and other.! Rates of up to 40 times acceptable U.S. standards 's air Resources is... To beat the trained British soldiers Assistant Professor of Economics to compare these numbers with another high-profile,... Who were affected by this corporate wrongdoing were angry and looking for justice our paper new..., taking the crown from Toyota about the fraud and environmental groups are questioning the legitimacy VW... Piece of kit are the health impacts like heart attacks and deaths figure out a to! New empirical evidence that the company said Vahland was leaving due to differing views on the road worldwide involved. Has returned to profitability for the year, it was the worlds automaker. Heavily sanctioned by financial markets and lost some 30 % of diesel vehicles in the U.S. and 11 worldwide! The analysts said in a slower Chinese market, Mercedes-Benz is catching up with competition in.! Simple questions: did you know about the fraud and lost some 30 % of the health burden air...
Non Prosecution Agreement, Who Has The Most Punishments In Impractical Jokers, Caywood Funeral Home Obituaries, Articles H